Thursday, May 25, 2023
HomeBusinessEvaluation | Why Do We Make It So Straightforward to Steal Seniors’...

Evaluation | Why Do We Make It So Straightforward to Steal Seniors’ Cash?


Regulators attempting to crack down on monetary fraud have actually had their fingers full currently.

They notched a uncommon win on Dec. 20, when Wells Fargo & Co. introduced it might pay $3.7 billion to settle a client fraud allegation by the Shopper Monetary Safety Bureau — $1.7 billion as a civil penalty and $2 billion for restitution to shoppers.

The settlement exposes only a few methods thieves mislead folks to take their cash. On this case, it was a significant financial institution benefiting from clients on mortgages, auto loans and overdraft charges. In keeping with the CFPB, “Customers have been illegally assessed charges and curiosity prices on auto and mortgage loans, had their automobiles wrongly repossessed, and had funds to auto and mortgage loans misapplied by the financial institution.”

{That a} well-established financial institution like Wells Fargo has been compelled to compensate its clients ought to elevate fears about different, newer kinds of monetary fraud. Freelance fraudsters have additionally been busy currently, in some instances benefiting from novel monetary merchandise, like Venmo and Zelle, or conditions, like Covid stimulus checks.

A scarcity of enough safeguards has made it too simple for criminals to prey on the unwary — particularly on American senior residents.

The nation’s 401K system is partly in charge. It asks retirees to handle giant monetary accounts proper concerning the age cognitive decline has the best danger of setting in. Malevolent folks know this. In contrast to a conventional pension or annuity, the place a retiree will get an everyday test however doesn’t entry the capital, the 401(ok) system primarily safety-pins a thousand-dollar invoice to grandma’s jacket and places her on a bus alone. It’s a state of affairs ripe for fraud.

The Senate Getting older Committee led by Bob Casey of Pennsylvania and Tim Scott of South Carolina held hearings in September to zero in on frauds and scams that focus on seniors. Predatory schemes have existed for many years, however the pandemic made issues worse as thieves preyed on seniors’ isolation and households’ stimulus checks.

Thieves have posed as federal and state companies to steal authorities advantages. Others reap the benefits of cellular cost apps — assume Zelle, Venmo, CashApp and PayPal — which make it simple to cowl their tracks. Generally, the fraudsters do each: Retired faculty bus driver and widow Aurelia Costigan from Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, was scammed out of $1,800 (she received it again) by a person posing as a financial institution official who warned her of an unauthorized cost from Tennessee and stated that she wanted a Zelle account and her Social Safety quantity to guard her account.

Old school reward playing cards are additionally ripe for fraud: In 2021, 27% of adults 60 and older who misplaced cash paid a scammer utilizing a present card. In these scams, the fraudsters typically pose as would-be lovers to realize entry to a senior’s cash, Marti DeLiema of the College of Minnesota has defined. Romance scams lead the pack when it comes to prices to seniors; the typical individual over the age of 70 loses $10,000.

Monetary firms must be doing extra to forestall all of this. As an illustration, the reward card trade is aware of when cash is loaded onto a present card by a buyer in a single place after which redeemed instantly by somebody in one other place. However flagging that as suspicious exercise — or implementing decrease transaction limits — would price them cash.  

The federal government and regulators might additionally do extra than simply chase after the dangerous guys after they’ve stolen the cash. They may make older folks much less of a goal: Investing in Social Safety and different protected, dependable types of annuity-like retirement earnings would take that thousand-dollar-bill off of grandma’s lapel.

The CFPB has finished good work in cracking down on fraud at Wells Fargo. Sadly, there’s nonetheless loads of work left to do.

Extra From Bloomberg Opinion:

• Vacation Consumers, Skip the Retailer Credit score Playing cards: Alexis Leondis

• The Finest Present You Can Give Your Youngsters Is in a Boring Envelope: Stuart Trow

• Ought to You Belief TikTok, YouTube Finfluencers?: Erin Lowry

This column doesn’t essentially replicate the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its homeowners.

Teresa Ghilarducci is the Schwartz Professor of Economics on the New College for Social Analysis. She’s the co-author of “Rescuing Retirement” and a member of the board of administrators of the Financial Coverage Institute.

Extra tales like this can be found on



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments